Staying Soft Without Being Unprotected

Learning to love people genuinely without forgetting that I matter too.

This is probably one of the more open posts I've attempted. Please bear with me. It's an insight into some of the things I'm trying to learn through good counsel. I would encourage anyone reading it to look from both angles: as someone loved and someone called to love others. It's from my own notes, about me, and about what I am (trying) to learn.
I think I'm safe in saying that I care deeply about people. Sometimes that is a strength. Sometimes, if I am open, it is also where I get hurt.
I don't think I want to become the kind of person who stops caring. I don't want disappointment to make me cynical, betrayal to make me cold or criticism to make me suspicious of everyone.
I still want to love people genuinely. I still want to listen. I still want to understand what may be happening underneath someone's behaviour rather than immediately assuming the worst. I still want to believe the best where I reasonably can. (1 Cor. 13:7)
But I am also learning that loving people does not mean giving everybody unlimited access to my heart. I am still called to care and continue to love, but I do not have to let anyone into my space if that repeatedly causes harm. And I forget that sometimes.
I can care about someone without carrying everything
One of the things I have noticed about myself is that when a relationship becomes distant or difficult, my instinct is often to examine it. A counsellor once told me that I can overanalyse myself and situations, sometimes far more than other people seem willing to examine their own part. I can see that.
What happened? What did I say? What have I done? What changed? What did they mean? Could I have handled it differently? Did I push them? Have I misunderstood them? Are they hurting? Is there something in their past, or maybe mine, which helps explain their reaction?
Those questions can be healthy. Self-examination matters (Gal. 6:4). Empathy matters (Rom. 12:15). Listening matters (Jas. 1:19). Christians should be willing to consider whether we have contributed to a problem rather than immediately defending ourselves.
But there is another side to this. Sometimes I can keep analysing because somewhere inside I am still hoping that, if I understand everything properly, I can somehow make everything right. It's a painful way my brain seems to work. And sometimes I cannot understand it or make everything right. That is difficult for me to accept.
There are also situations where I can understand why somebody behaves the way they do and still recognise that the behaviour is not healthy. They may behave a certain way because they are frightened. They may be insecure. They may have experienced rejection. Their upbringing may have been unstable. They may carry wounds I don't know about.
All of those things can help me respond with compassion. But explanation is not the same thing as permission. Understanding why somebody behaves badly does not require me to pretend the behaviour is harmless. And recognising somebody else's pain does not mean I have to continually absorb the consequences of it.
I am responsible for my part, not everybody's response
Romans 12:18 has become increasingly important to me:
“If it is possible, as far as it depends on you, live at peace with everyone.”
There is a lot of responsibility in that verse. But there are also limits.
If it is possible. As far as it depends on you.
I can examine myself honestly. I can apologise where I have been wrong. I can listen. I can explain where explanation is helpful. I can forgive and I am good at that. I can try to keep my heart free from bitterness. I can leave the door open where that is wise.
But, as much as I want to, I cannot make another person understand me. I cannot force someone to trust me. I cannot make somebody respond graciously. I cannot manufacture reconciliation just by myself.
And perhaps one of the things I am still learning is that I do not have to keep trying forever just because a relationship matters to me. Sometimes I have already done what depends upon me. There comes a point where I have to allow another person to carry what depends upon them.
Someone being upset with me does not automatically mean I have done something wrong
This one is difficult for caring people. If somebody is upset with us, disappointed in us or angry about a decision we have made, it can feel as though that emotional response itself proves we must have done something wrong.
Sometimes it does reveal something we need to examine. But not always. Sometimes a loving decision still disappoints someone. Sometimes a boundary hurts. Sometimes saying no hurts. Sometimes correction hurts. Sometimes a change in a relationship hurts. Sometimes leadership decisions affect people in ways we genuinely wish they didn't.
I should care about that. I do. Maybe too much at times. But love should at least make me consider the impact of my words, behaviour and decisions upon other people.
However, I am gradually learning that someone being hurt by a decision does not automatically mean I have hurt them wrongly. There is a difference.
Jesus loved people perfectly, and people still became angry with Him. Some walked away. Some misunderstood Him. Some accused Him. Some wanted things from Him which He did not give them.
So, love is not measured simply by whether everybody remains pleased with me. Love is willing to serve, willing to stay, willing to pursue relationship and willing to listen. And love sometimes says no.
Love does not require unlimited access
John records something about Jesus which I find interesting. In John 2:24 he says:
“But Jesus would not entrust himself to them, for he knew all people.”
That is quite striking. Jesus loved people. He gave Himself for people. He showed extraordinary compassion. Yet John also tells us that there were some people to whom Jesus did not entrust Himself. That at least reminds me that loving somebody and entrusting myself to them are not necessarily the same thing.
There were crowds. There were disciples. There were the Twelve. There were Peter, James and John. Sometimes I wonder what circle people fit into in my life. But I also see there were times when Jesus withdrew altogether. That has challenged some of my assumptions about what real love looks like.
I think I have sometimes confused being loving with being endlessly available, and they are not the same thing. I can also care about somebody without telling them everything. I can want God's best for somebody without allowing them into every vulnerable place in my life, especially if they don't hold my heart kindly. I may be held to a pastoral standard, but I too am human and I matter too.
I can forgive somebody without immediately restoring the same level of trust. I can remain kind while recognising that a relationship needs different boundaries. And that is not necessarily hardness. Sometimes it is wisdom.
Of course, trust can be rebuilt. But trust is not automatically restored simply because forgiveness has begun. Forgiveness, reconciliation, trust and access are related, but they are not the same thing. And access should normally reflect the health of the relationship.
I don't always need to make somebody love me or understand me
This may be one of the harder lessons for me. Possibly? Maybe? No, it is! When I feel misunderstood or unloved, particularly by someone I care about, I want to explain. And over-explain! Then I want to lovingly pursue. And over-pursue!
Sometimes explanation is good because misunderstandings should often be cleared up. But there comes a point where explanation stops being communication and starts becoming an attempt to obtain reassurance.
If I can just find the right words...
If I can explain my motives properly...
If I can convey how much I love them...
If I can show them what I really meant... perhaps then everything will feel safe again.
But sometimes another person has already reached their conclusion. And continuing to explain myself will not change it. At that point, I need something deeper than their agreement. I need to remember that God already knows. He knows what happened. He knows what I intended. He knows my heart. He also knows the parts I got wrong. He sees my motives more clearly than I do.
That means I can still examine myself honestly without handing another person's opinion final authority over who I am.
Peter says something beautiful about Jesus in 1 Peter 2:23:
“When they hurled their insults at him, he did not retaliate... Instead, he entrusted himself to him who judges justly.”
Jesus did not need everybody to understand Him correctly before He could entrust Himself to the Father. I am still learning that. It is a process, but I am learning.
Sometimes the healthiest thing I can say is:
God knows my heart. I will correct what is mine to correct, but I do not have to make everybody see me correctly before I can be at peace.
Compassion can become over-responsibility
There is another danger for people who naturally care. My counsellor keeps coming back to this. The penny will drop eventually, I pray! I can begin taking responsibility for things that do not actually belong to me.
If somebody is unhappy, I must fix it. If somebody withdraws, I must repair it. If somebody feels rejected, I must have rejected them. If somebody becomes angry, I must somehow have caused the anger.
But people's emotions are more complicated than that. Of course my behaviour affects others, so I should never use boundaries as an excuse for selfishness or insensitivity. Love does consider the impact we have upon people. But my mind can repeat these considerations in a loop until I am emotionally empty, hurting and exhausted.
I am not responsible for regulating every other adult's emotions. I am not responsible for protecting everyone from disappointment. And I am not responsible for keeping every relationship emotionally comfortable.
Sometimes another person's reaction belongs partly to their history, their expectations, their interpretation or their choices. And compassion allows me to recognise that without condemning them, while boundaries allow me to recognise it without carrying it for them.
I matter too
Even writing those words feels slightly uncomfortable. I want to cringe. I matter too.
I think I find it awkward because Christian language quite rightly teaches us to deny ourselves, serve others and consider their needs. Philippians 2:4 calls us to look beyond our own interests to the interests of others. The NKJV puts it particularly helpfully: ‘Let each of you look out not only for his own interests, but also for the interests of others.’ That isn't a command to pretend we have no legitimate needs, responsibilities or limits. It is a call away from selfishness towards Christlike concern for others.
There is a difference between self-denial and self-erasure though. Jesus tells us to love our neighbour as ourselves. Christian love is outward-looking, sacrificial and generous. But I don't believe God asks us to become emotionally invisible.
My wellbeing matters. My responsibilities matter. My capacity matters. My conscience matters. My limits matter. And sometimes protecting those things is not selfishness.
It is stewardship.
I still forget that. I can become so focused on how somebody else feels that I lose sight of what is happening inside me. Sometimes I only realise later that I am exhausted, hurt or quietly carrying far more than I should. I am learning, or trying, to notice that sooner. Not so that I become self-absorbed. But because healthy love needs healthy boundaries if it is going to remain love rather than resentment.
Guarding my heart without closing it
Proverbs tells us: “Above all else, guard your heart, for everything you do flows from it.”
In context, this is about guarding the inner life from what shapes it, but I think there is a helpful principle here for relationships too. For a long time I think I heard guard your heart almost as though it meant becoming suspicious. Build safe walls around it. Expect disappointment. Keep people at a distance. But I don't think that is what I want. I am by default more open-hearted. So I want a guarded heart without a closed heart.
There is a difference.
A closed heart says: "I will never let anyone hurt me again."
A guarded heart says: "I will love, but I will also use wisdom."
A closed heart refuses vulnerability.
A guarded heart gives vulnerability where trust has been built.
A closed heart assumes danger.
A guarded heart recognises danger when it appears.
A closed heart becomes hard.
A guarded heart can remain soft.
I think this is what I am trying to learn.
Jesus was both compassionate and boundaried
I'm beginning to notice how often Jesus did things that would have disappointed people.
He withdrew when people wanted access to Him. He refused some demands. He challenged people who wanted affirmation. He walked away from crowds. He allowed the rich young ruler to leave. He loved people deeply without becoming governed by their responses to Him.
And yet nobody could reasonably describe Jesus as emotionally detached. He wept. He was moved with compassion. He welcomed children. He touched people others avoided. He restored people. He noticed individuals in crowds. He loved extraordinarily.
That is the balance I want.
Jesus once told His disciples to be “as shrewd as snakes and as innocent as doves.”
There is something there for relationships too. Wisdom without cynicism. Innocence without naïvety. Compassion without self-erasure. Boundaries without bitterness.
I am still learning this!
I wish I could say I always get this right. I don't.
Sometimes I still explain too much. Sometimes I still carry things longer than I should. Sometimes love still feels like it hurts. Sometimes somebody's disappointment gets under my skin more deeply than I would like. Sometimes I forget that another person's interpretation of me is not the same thing as God's judgement of me. Sometimes I pursue reconciliation when it's not mine to reconcile. Sometimes I still try to repair things that may not currently be mine to repair. And sometimes I still need reminding that I matter too.
But I don't want the answer to be becoming less loving. I want to become better at loving. I don't want hurt to make me suspicious. I don't want betrayal to make me inaccessible. I don't want criticism to make me defensive. I don't want boundaries to make me cold.
But neither do I want love to mean having no boundaries, endlessly explaining myself, exposing myself to constant rejection, taking responsibility for everybody's feelings or repeatedly giving unsafe people access to vulnerable places in me.
I want to stay soft-hearted. But I also want to become wiser. I want to understand people's wounds without allowing their wounds to continually wound me. I want to forgive without pretending trust has not been damaged. I want to care without carrying what belongs to somebody else. I want to remain open without becoming unprotected.
And when I cannot make somebody understand my heart, when I cannot make someone love me, I want to learn to entrust myself to the One who already does.
Maybe that is part of maturity too. Not caring less. Not loving less. But learning how to love people genuinely without continually losing myself in the process.
© 2026 Darren Roy
NOTE: Related psychological themes
Some of the themes touched on in this article connect with psychological concepts such as rumination, people-pleasing, rejection sensitivity, over-responsibility, reassurance-seeking, anxiety and difficulties with boundaries.
None of those terms is intended here as a diagnosis. They are just useful concepts that may help describe some of the patterns discussed.
Some of these difficulties can actually grow out of genuinely positive qualities, particularly in caring, pastoral or leadership roles. But strengths can become costly when they are overextended.
Empathy can become over-responsibility.
Conscientious self-examination can become rumination.
Wanting reconciliation can become reassurance-seeking or over-pursuit.
Sensitivity to other people can become interpersonal sensitivity or rejection sensitivity.
Generosity can become people-pleasing.
Pastoral availability can become poor boundaries.
None of that means the underlying quality is bad. Often the task is not to eliminate the quality, but to learn to regulate it more wisely and sustainably.




Thanks for your openess, I can relate to many of these. Your writing is beautiful too ❤️ grateful for you